
Iowa Beat Iowa State 20-15 last Saturday, setting the NCAA all-time attendance record for a wrestling meet at 15,955. That means a whole lot of people got to see Iowa kick Iowa State's collective asses in person, and even more were able to watch the spectacle on the Big Ten Network. More on that later. What follows is analysis of what I saw, with the aid of one week of cool and calm reflection.
First, at the outset, I was not terribly impressed with the effort the Hawkeyes put forward. Iowa Wrestling isn't a matter of winning or losing, it is a matter of domination. To quote Tom Brands' philosophy:
“You’re beating them physically, you’re beating them mentally, beating psychologically because you rest and eat right, and spiritually because you pray to the Lord Jesus Christ. You got five, or six or seven dimensions in that. You put it on a level your opponent cannot understand. He quits, not because he wants to, but because he has to. He has no choice.” — Tom Brands, Jan. 20, 2008Apart from Brent Metcalf's match, there was no domination--at any level--against Iowa State. Wrestlers who should have pulled away from their opponents to earn major decisions, only walked away with a win. Nowhere was this more true than in the first match of the night:
125--Charlie Falck (I) dec. Tyler Clark (ISU), 4-2--

Yawn. Charlie had a nice first takedown in the first period, and you have to give credit to Tyler Clark for keeping Falck from getting any back points. Charlie was clearly more proficient on his feet, and could very well have scored at will against Clark. He didn't. With that said, I have to temper my criticism, as the officials were
very slow to call stalements that would have moved the action forward. Furthermore, Clark quite clearly stalled his ass off to start the second. He made no effort to advance his position, being merely content to hang on. When you wrestling a staller, it is hard to rack up a big score. You have to expect more out of the number two wrestler in the country.
133--Nick Fanthrope (ISU) Maj. Dec. Joe Slaton (I), 12-2--
Picture: Probably the last time Slaton was on his feet during the match.I'll try to make this short. Slaton looked terrible. He looked as bad against ISU as I have ever seen an Iowa wrestler look against anyone. He got a quick first takedown, and then gassed. Some commentators have written that he even looked winded running on to the mat. I think that is a little harsh. What is clear though is Joe Slaton is not ready to wrestle.
What do I mean by that? I mean his weight isn't under control. Tom Brands came out and said, straight out, that Joe Slaton has spent too much of his time working on cutting weight, and that he made a coaching "mistake" putting Slaton out there instead of Iowa 133 pounder, and Grant High School Alum, Daniel Dennis. I don't think that Slaton is any less of a wrestler than he was last year, when he took 2nd at Nationals. The first 30 seconds of the match made clear the skills are still there. He just needs to get down to weight, and get his conditioning up to speed.
This is not to say that Nick Fanthrope is not a very good wrestler. Fanthrope, a Naperville North prodegy along with Eric Tannenbaum (Michigan) and Brian Dyer, is a stud. He is the kind of guy that will almost certainly be an All-American. However, he is not the kind of wrestler who should (a) beat Joe Slaton; and (b) he is most certainly not the kind of wrestler who should beat Joe Slaton by a major decision.
This is a news story I'd like to see the Press-Citizen pay some more attention to. If he isn't in peak shape by Midlands, problems are afoot.
141--Alex Tsirtsis (I) dec. Nick Gallick (ISU), 4-2--

Before Alex Tsirtsis, a 2007 All-American for the Hawkeyes who took a redshirt last year, beat Nick Gallick, the biggest news surrounding his return to the program was his long hair.
Let that talk be damned. Alex Tsirtsis provided one of the few bright spots to an otherwise mediocre meet. Tsirtsis, ranked #3 in the nation at the time of the duel, beat the #2 ranked wrestler. Anytime this happens, it is a positive. However, that doesn't nearly sum up why this was so good.
Part of it was the suspense--a last second reversal secured victory for Tsirtsis, causing the nearly 16,000 Hawkeye faithful to go nuts. Part of it is Tsirtsis' long and troubled road from wunderkind to meh and back again. For those not in the know, Tsirtsis was a 4x Indiana State Champ, went undefeated (or nearly so) in both high school, and national level competition, and was invited to compete in the prestigous Midlands Tourney as a senior at Griffith High Schol in Indiana. When a sagging Iowa team landed him as a recruit, it was a major coups. I first saw him at that Midlands tournement. He was confident, and incredibly explosive. While he didn't place, he came damn close.
Last week, Tsirtsis reclaimed some of that confidence, showing the world is speed and skill with an amazing sweep single in the first period. Doug Schwab, who wrestled for the United States in this past Olympics, commented to the press that Tsirtsis' shot was the kind that scored in world-competition. This may have been Tsirtsis' coming-out party, so-to-speak. Now, if he can hit more than one of those amazing shots....
149--Brent Metcalf (I) Tech. Fall Mitch Mueller (ISU), 26-10 in 6:14
Picture: ISU Wrestler: "Please don't hurt me!"
Guns don't kill people, Brent Metcalf kills people.
Brent Metcalf doesn't sleep, he waits.
Brent Metcalf's tears cure cancer. Too bad he has never cried.
Brent Metcalf destroyed the periodic table, because he only recognizes the element of surprise.
When the Boogeyman goes to sleep every night, he checks his closet for Brent Metcalf.
Outer space exists because it is afraid to be on the same planet as Brent Metcalf.
Brent Metcalf is the reason why Waldo is hiding.
157--Cyler Sanderson (ISU) Maj. Dec. Matt Ballweg (I), 22-9--
Cyler Sanderson is good, maybe not as good as his famous older brother Cael, but still pretty damn good. He was able to shoot on Ballweg at will. Kudos to Ballweg for not losing via tec. fall. Look for Cyler to win at a few national championships before he is done clowning-around.
165--Ryan Morningstar (I) dec. Jon Reader (ISU), 2-0--
Ryan Morningstar is easily the most frustrating Hawkeye wrestler for me to watch. Make no bones about it, this was a gigantic win for him--Morningstar was ranked number 9 in the nation, while Reader was ranked number 3. What frustrates me is that Morningstar, if he was consistent, would be hammering people like Reader all day long.
A little history. I first saw Morningstar wrestle when he was a junior at Lisbon High School. The match was televised in the dorms, and I was able to watch him win his second of three eventual state championships. Then, and now, I have never seen a high school wrestler who looked slicker on his feet. I saw Eric Tannenbaum (Michigan, multiple AA), Mike Poeta (Illinois, Multiple AA, current national titer contender), Jimmy Kennedy (Illinois, AA), Daniel Dennis (Iowa 133) and many other tough kids. None looked tougher than Morningstar.
So, imagine my shock and surprise, when Morningstar shows up at Iowa, and doesn't look slick at all on his feet. Hell, he beat Reader via his riding prowess--which was pretty damn amazing. What will happen if Morningstar is ever able to open up his offense, and unlease his full potential? Hopefully we find out before the season is over.
174--Jay Borschel (I) dec. Duke Burk (ISU), 6-2--Perfect example of the Hawkeyes doing just enough to win, and not nearly enough to really separate themselves from the competition. This should have been a major decision. Anything less is just unaceptable. With that said, Burk is pretty tough. I still expect to see Jay Borschel being interviewed after he wins a national championship at the end of the year.
184--Phillip Keddy (I) dec. Jerome Ward (ISU), 3-2--The story of this match wasn't Phillip Keddy's failure to get a major decision against Jerome Ward. It was how good Jerome Ward looked. True, Ward spent most of the match stalling his ass off. But, what do you expect from an ISU wrestler? Ward, a product of a very good St. Rita program in Chicago, looked instantly ready to compete. Should be an interesting battle next year, but for the rest of this year I expect Keddy to widden his margin of victory against this talented youngster.
197--Jake Varner (ISU) Maj. Dec. Luke Lofthouse (I), 13-3--It is nice to see that Luke Lofthouse is back from his Mormon Mission. It was also nice to see that he put up a serious fight, and put the duel meet out of reach for ISU by not being pinned. With that said, this was a serious mismatch. Iowa needs to be competitive at every weightclass, and if this manhandling is any indication, we are not competitive nationally at 197.
Hwt.--David Zabriskie (ISU) dec. Dan Erekson (I), 5-1--This match was a lot closer than the score indicates, and I'm genuinely excited about the prospects of having Erekson at heavyweight. At one point in the second period, if my memory serves me correctly, Erekson was inches away from sticking Zabriskie. It is nice to have a pinner at heavyweight, and certainly exciting. A shame Erekson got careless, and gave up some stupid takedowns at the end of periods. Oh, well. Live and learn.
---
Overall, I give the Hawkeyes a C+. Disgustingly poor performance by Slaton, good performances by Morningstar and Tsirtsis. Everyone else was mediocre. If we can beat a team like Iowa State when we wrestle poorly, it will be scary to see how we do when the Hawkeyes wrestle well.